Alpha STAR’s GENOA, A Verified Commercial Software for Durability, Virtual Testing, and Reliability in Monolithic/Laminated/ Braided/Woven/Stitched Composite Structure

Feature Description

GENOA is an integrated structural analysis/design software suite originally developed to cost effectively predicts strength, reliability and durability of aerospace structural components at the design stage with minimal experimental testing support. GENOA progressive failure analysis predicts the crack initiation, growth, and final failure of monolithic and 2D/3D braided/laminated /stitched/woven composite materials. GENOA evaluates the structural and material response including degradation of material properties due to initiation and growth of damage under static, dynamic, thermal, impact, creep, and low/high frequency cyclic fatigue loading conditions Failure prediction takes into account defects introduced by: 1) manufacturing, 2) in-service operations and environments, 3) fatigue, and 4) material creep.

The modeling of PMC in GENOA considers physics and mechanics of composite materials and structure by integration of a Hierarchical Multi-Level Macro Scale (lamina, laminate, and structure) and Micro Scale (fiber, matrix, and interface) for simulation analyses. Modeling with GENOA involves: 1) ply layering methodology utilizing FEM elements that include through-the-thickness representation, 2) simulation of effects of material properties and defects (voids, fiber weaviness, residual stress) on global static and cyclic fatigue strengths, 3) simulation of crack initiation, and growth to failure under static, cyclic, creep, and impact loads, and 4) progressive fracture analysis to determine durability and damage tolerance, 5) identifying the percent contribution of various possible composite failure modes involved in critical damage events, and 6) determining sensitivities of failure modes to design parameters (e.g. fiber volume fraction, ply thickness, fiber orientation, and adhesive bond thickness) to facilitate targeting design parameter changes that will be most effective in reducing the probability of a given failure mode occurring

Key Analysis Features:

Examples of Primary Applications:

Simulation of discrete source damage effect on Durability and Damage Tolerance of a large Aircraft Wing-Eight three stringer polymer composite Stitched/Resin Film infusion (S/RFI) panels were simulated in support of the NASA-Boeing/Long Beach ACT program for design of a large commercial aircraft wing. Pre test simulation predictions were within 93.5 to 99 percent of subsequent experimental tension and compression strength test results. Further, predictions of damage initiation, damage growth path, strain distributions, and photo elastic fringe patterns correlated well with test results. Sensitivity of damage growth to damage initiation shape was predicted per FAA requirements. Experimental testing was significantly facilitated relative to determination of: 1) load application, 2) strain gage locations, and 3) anticipated crack development.

Simulation of full scale Mini Space Plane Vehicle-in support of the Air Force-Boeing/Seal Beach Mini Space Plane Technology (MIST) program. The GENOA-PFA software successfully predicted damage tolerance limits and failure criteria of the Mini Space Technology Plane (MIST) by using a building-block strategy to numerically) calibrate material strength and stiffness properties with data from tape and fabric composite coupon tests, and 2) predict the D&DT (involving damage initiation, accumulation, and residual strength) of the full scale test article under combined longitudinal, torsional, and shear loads. GENOA-PFA used finite element models (FEMs) to analyze subcomponents made of composite materials, taking into account ply drop-off, voids, and fiber volume ratios. Details of composite thickness, lay-up configuration, voids and flaws were provided by Boeing Tulsa Division from results of ultrasonic jet flow machine inspection of fuselage crown, side, and bottom areas. Verification was achieved by successfully predicting test results of 1) residual strength (within 1.0%), 2) multiple crack initiation and growth locations , and 3) strain measurements. It was shown that global fracture initiation and fracture propagation occur at maximum and minimum of the Total Energy Release Rate (TDERR) values, respectively.

Simulation Acoustic Fatigue effects on Durability of Lockheed F22- Aircraft Composite Panel - Damage initiation, growth, accumulation, and propagation to fracture due to cyclic fatigue were simulated. Results showed the damage progression sequence and the changes in the structural response characteristics during different degradation stages and allowed. assessment of damage tolerance, determination of sensitive parameters affecting fracture, and interpretation of experimental results with insight for design decisions. Significant findings were: 1) the number of load cycles to failure was an approximately exponential function of the acoustic amplitude, 2) degradation of the first natural frequency was a function of the number of acoustic load cycles, 3) the first damage growth stage affects the fundamental structural response significantly, and 4) the damage propagation stages immediately prior to structural fracture do not influence the first natural frequency very much.

Probabilistic Fatigue Life Analysis of Boeing Crown Panel, and Integrally Assembled (IAS Panel Lap Joint In The presence of MSD –The Progressive Failure Analysis by probabilistic fatigue life and durability and damage tolerance computative simulation analyses of a lap joint in an IAS coupon and in IAS panel structures with multi site damage. Deterministic progressive failure analysis (PFA) simulations were performed by Alpha STAR Corporation using its GENOA software and information obtained from Boeing. Finite element models, meshes of a test coupon and two test panels, with and without multi site damage, were prepared. Test results from the coupon with static and cyclic fatigue simulation analyses were conducted to determine in detail the effects of multi site damage on ultimate loads and cycles to failure after calibrating the software. In the course of these simulation analyses, damage initiation and progression were determined as functions of static and cyclic loading.

Deterministic accomplishments of this effort were: 1) PFA verification with data from five coupon tests, crown panel static test, and the crown panel fatigue test, 2) PFA analysis of the static lap joint model (extracted from the Boeing crown panel FEM model), 3) PFA analysis of the fatigue lap joint model (extracted from the Boeing crown panel model), and 4) PFA analysis of the fatigue lap joint model (extracted from the Boeing crown panel FEM model) using 5 percent variation of lap joint thicknesses. A comparison of simulation and experimental test results is shown in Table 1-1.

Probabilistic analysis accomplishments of this effort were probabilistic simulation of: 1) the static lap joint model for critical failure modes at the crack initiation site (at pressure load of 29.4 psi), and 2) fatigue of the lap joint model for critical failure modes at the crack initiation site (at pressure load of 29.4 psi). 


Table 1-1 Summary of Results From Testing and Deterministic Simulation Analyses
 
Specimen
Loading condition
Maximum stress
Simulation
Testing
NASA Coupon Static Loading (ultimate load)   14060 LB 13500 LB
Cyclic Loading (cycle to failure) 22KSI 84,000 81,541
18KSI 204,800 153,951 (test 1)
239,361 (test 2)
154,142 (test 3)
16KSI 324,100 313,138
Boeing Crown Panel Static Loading (ultimate load)   10.48 PSI ~10.3 PSI
Cyclic Loading (cycle to failure)   10,720 10,333
 
 

Probabilistic Assessment of Fracture in Stitched and Unstitched Composite Laminates-Structural response is assessed probabilistically during degradation. The effects of design variable uncertainties on structural damage progression are quantified. The Fast Probability Integrator is used to assess the response scatter in the composite structure at damage initiation. Sensitivity of the damage response to design variables is computed. Methods are general purpose in nature and are applicable to stitched and unstitched composites in all types of structures and fracture processes starting from damage initiation to unstable propagation and to global structure collapse. The methods are demonstrated for polymer matrix composite panels under edge loads. Results indicate that composite constituent properties and fabrication parameters have a significant effect on structural durability. Design implications with regard to damage progression and damage tolerance of composite structures are examined.

Allied Signal Engine Combustor Development- The effort centered on enhancement of GENOATM, to simulate 2D/3D-braided/woven CMC material to simulate: 1) 3D-woven/braided fiber architecture, and 2) track micro/macro damage (initiation, accumulation, stable growth, and fracture). GENOA predictions made for code verification by comparison with CMC coupon and combustor test data from: 1) Nicalon/SIC CMC compact tension coupon test results reported in the literature, and 2) Sylramic/MI CMC coupon tests (bending, flexural, open hole (0.25, 0.38 in diameters) tension and unnotched) available from an Alpha STAR cooperative effort with GE/NASA’s HSR-EPM program and AE full-scale combustor rig test. Verifications of GENOA predictions were made relative to CMC strength, stiffness, and creep rupture. AE’s CMC combustor model was simulated to predict fracture paths and life cycles under service conditions. GENOA predictions correlated well with the fracture pattern exhibited on experimental testing of AE’s Nicalon/SiC CMC combustor. GENOA was also used to predict the fracture path in AE’s projected Sylramic/MI CMC combustor for comparison with their Nicalon/SiC CMC combustor.

Air Born Laser -The STI-optronics laser reactor housing of the airborne laser laboratory is a lightweight structure that is made of composite materials that are loaded statically and dynamically. Alpha Star Corporation (ASC) has conducted static stress analysis to determine which areas are highly loaded and areas, which require design modifications to prevent structural failure. The GENOA durability and damage tolerance (D&DT) simulation software has been successfully used to predict susceptibility to damage under service loading of the STI-optronics laser reactor housing. The GENOA analysis combines details of the composite structure lay-up, a rough finite element model defining the geometry, material properties and structural loading with advanced methods of damage tolerance fracture mechanics to provide crack initiation, crack growth and lifetime fatigue predictions. The GENOA simulation evaluated one piece and adhesive bonded structural designs of the STI-optronics housings made of: 1) carbon-carbon composite and fiber glass honeycomb core, and 2) carbon-carbon composite and titanium honeycomb core. Simulation of D&DT was achieved by utilizing CATIA for solid geometric modeling, and GENOA for mathematical modeling of progressive failure and reliability. The results of the GENOA simulations have provided insight needed for significant reduction of the time and cost required for the design of the 21st century commercial laser reactor housing structure.

Verification with coupon test results

Strength and fracture pattern Simulations - of (S/RFI) Polymer composite compact tension, center cracked, and inclined cracked coupons were made and verified, to be within 99% of corresponding test data from NASA.

Strength and stiffness Simulations-of (S/RFI) Polymer composite. open-hole tension, open-hole compression, Isopescue shear, unnotched compression and unnotched tension coupons were made and verified to be within 97% of corresponding test data from University of California at Santa Barbara (UCSB).

Strength and Stiffness Simulations-of ten lightly and heavily compacted woven composite coupons were made and verified to be within 97% of corresponding test data from Rockwell Science Center.

 

Table 1. PMC Progressive Failure simulation Key Multi-disciplinary Features
 
Features
PFA Loading Condition
Functionality
Durability
And
Damage
Tolerance-
Static
  • Damage initiation and location (fiber, matrix or interface ) within a lamina, 
  • Percent of contributing failure mechanisms
  • Failure location , and fracture path within lamina, and structure
  • Residual strength after damage
  • Prediction of life cycle
  • Prediction of s-n curves, da/dn, and fracture toughness 
  • Stress intensity factor
  • Prediction of material property degradation cycle
  • Animated graphics of pfa process
Static cycling
Fatigue-harmonic loading
Fatigue-random 
Impact (pseudo–static)
Impact -dynamics)
Virtual
Testing
Static
  • Contour plots of the global strain/stress fields at crack initiation, propagation, and failure
  • Plot of far-field applied load vs. Deflection (deflectometer)
  • Plot of applied load vs. Strain (strain gage)
  • Photo-elastic fringe simulation (isochromatic, and isoclinic)
  • Local and global energy release rates vs. Applied loads representing acoustic emissions
  • Plot of crack length vs. Applied load to show the fracture toughness
  • Plots of stress vs. Strain at selected locations
  • Predictions of static failure resulting from discrete source damage ( dsd)
  • Prediction fatigue damage initiation at multiple sites
  • Prediction of required tests based on sensitivity of failure criteria
  • Movie play of virtual testing process
Static cycling
Fatigue-harmonic 
Impact (pseudo–static)
Impact –dynamics)
Probabilistic Failure Analysis
Static
  • Uncertainty evaluation of material strength to material parameters 
  • Sensitivities of design requirements to design parameters. 
  • Predicting the degree to which design parameters contributed to failure 
  • Generation of cumulative distribution functions (cdf) for failure strength evaluation
  • Probability of time to failure 
  • Margin of safety predictions 
Static cycling
Fatigue-harmonic 
Impact (pseudo–static)
Impact - dynamics
Manufacturing of Preform Composite Net Part Shape
Static
  • Fiber orientation and volume fraction changes
  • Attainable best fit to a shape, 
  • Minimize occurrences of failure (buckling, fiber wrinkling)
  • Simulating multiple reshaped preforms of different sizes interleaved with woven sheet strips
  • Transferring fiber orientation data directly to design and manufacturing process software
  • Animated graphics of manufacturing process
Equivalent Laminate Properties
Laminated, 2D/3D woven/braided/Stitched
  • Equivalent laminate moduli, moisture property, thermal property, , and heat conductivity
  • Degradation of material properties due to environmental factors (moisture, thermal), or manufacturing (voids, defects, residual strains)
  • Plot of ply strength vs. Ply stress
 

 

 

Table 2. Demonstrated Progressive Failure Analysis (PFA) Capabilities
 
Verified PFA Simulation
Primary Methodology
Project
Company/Agency
Residual Strength, Fracture Pattern, Design Curves, DSD Effects, & Stress/Strain Distributions in S/RFI Composite Structure PFA under static loading of Stitched/Resin Film Infusion  Analytical and Experimental Verification of DSD In S/RFI Commercial Aircraft  Boeing -AST/NASA-LaRC
Comparison with full scale X40 test article (Residual Strength, failure location)  PFA under static loading of laminated sandwich (tape, honeycomb, fabric) structure X40 Structural Test Demonstrator Boeing/NASA-LaRC
Support full scale design of laser reactor housing (crack initiation, residual Strength, and failure location)  PFA (under static loading) including, probabilistic analysis of laminated sandwich (honeycomb, fabric) structure Air born Laser Reactor housing DOD/Boeing/TRW/STI-Optronics
Acoustic fatigue failure from random vibration shake test PFA (under acoustic random loading) Lockheed F22 adhesively bonded airfoil coupon joints Lockheed
Determining Changes in Orientation Angles, Sissoring Lock-up, and Preform Geometry on Reshaping Braided/Woven Fiber Preforms Fiber Preform Reshaping in manufacturing  NASA/AST composite affordability NASA-LeRC
GE-90 Turbine Engine Blade General Electric Aircraft Engine
Windmill Generator Blade Sandia National Laboratory/ Goldsworthy
Residual strength after projectile Impact on PMC component  PFA (under impact loading) Verification for PMC component design NASA-White sands
Probabilistic fatigue life analysis of Integrally assembled structure (IAS) panel lap joint in the presence of multi site damage (MSD)  PFA of riveted orthotropic aluminum structure (under static and fatigue loading) including, probabilistic analysis  Verification for 747 Crown Panel component redesign Boeing (Long Beach) NASA-LaRC
Progressive and Probabilistic fatigue life analysis of composite reinforced structure  Laminate analogy for composite enhanced concrete structures  Simulation of composite reinforced Concrete arch, and panels for repair of infrastructure component redesign National Institute of Standard (NIST)
 

Product Strategy

GENOA is a modular, heterogeneous software system that can be easily ported to any hardware platform using a UNIX, and NT operating systems. Several stand alone modules are offered as a package or selectively purchased according to the users specific needs. The Graphic User Interface (GUI) and Executive Controller System (ECS) together make up the main driver for one or all of the modules and are a required part of GENOA. The GUI provides the pre and post processor visualization capability while the menu driven ECS connects all the modules. The following is a brief description of GENOA’s drivers and modules.

Graphic User Interface (GUI) - - A visualization system based on ICONS and menus. The main functions of GUI are: 1) to provide visualization to view results, 2) to import CAD models from PATRAN or NASTRAN, and 3) to export data to other software systems such as NASTRAN or PATRAN. GUI is written in C language and employs a standard graphical library such as X11 Motif and OPENGL, on-line help options spanning from input deck preparation, post processing plots, and contour plots. GUI allows visualization of the updated Lagrangian: 1) FEM model, 2) FEM stresses/strains/photo-elastic fringe pattern, 3) ply stresses, 4) micro-stresses, 5) damage locations, 6) percent contribution of failure mechanism to failure, 7) location of failed nodes, and 8) XY plot history of strain, TDERR, DERR, %damage, and strength degradation plots.

Code Name: GENOA

Source: Alpha STAR Corporation

Cost: Please contact us.

Outputs: Graphical representation of Damaged plies/nodes, photo-elastic fringe, stress/strain field, damage history profile.

Documentation: User’s manual, and Training Manual, on line help menu

Interface: Interfaces with other Commercial analysis codes: PATRAN, ANSYS, and NASTRAN

Supported Computer Platforms: Silicon Graphics, Hewlett Packard, WINDOWS, UNIX, LINUX

Additional Software or Hardware Required: 500 MB Storage, 512 MB Memory 




Architecture of GENOA Durability &Reliability Software System


 
FeedbackProductsCurrent ResearchPartnersAbout CompanyAlpha STAR Corporation Home Page